Went for their Tuesday greek night.. it was delicious! Small salad was big enough for dinner and left overs for... read moreWent for their Tuesday greek night.. it was delicious! Small salad was big enough for dinner and left overs for lunch the next day! I added the gyro meat and it was so good! Will def be back soon! read less

Solid food, large menu, generous servings, very quick service. They take cards & are a 15 min drive from Brookhaven... read moreSolid food, large menu, generous servings, very quick service. They take cards & are a 15 min drive from Brookhaven National Lab. Located in a strip mall. Small space but not too loud. read less

Breakfast was awesome.chunky monkey pancakes were outstanding as well as the pumpkin pancakes. Service was the best we've had in... read moreBreakfast was awesome.chunky monkey pancakes were outstanding as well as the pumpkin pancakes. Service was the best we've had in a long time. Food. came out really fast as well even though they were crowded on a Sunday morning.I highly recommend stopping here if you are in the wading river area! read less

Great place! Very nice atmosphere and the staff is very friendly and attentive. Plenty of Gluten Free options and they... read moreGreat place! Very nice atmosphere and the staff is very friendly and attentive. Plenty of Gluten Free options and they are very careful with prep. Food is great! read less

Always a pleasure eating here. The staff is extremely friendly and the food is always delicious. Highly recommended for breakfast,... read moreAlways a pleasure eating here. The staff is extremely friendly and the food is always delicious. Highly recommended for breakfast, lunch or dinner! read less

Excellent Food And Service We recently got takeout for five people and our order was promptly filled in twenty minutes. The food was delicious... read moreWe recently got takeout for five people and our order was promptly filled in twenty minutes. The food was delicious and the portions were large. read less

Nothing bad to say Love this place. Food is great super fast service even when busy excellent service All employees super friendly from the... read moreLove this place. Food is great super fast service even when busy excellent service All employees super friendly from the cashier to waitress to bus boy Good for breakfast lunch and dinner. read less

WOW WOW WOW. I went here last night and fell in love. My mom had been mentioning how good the... read moreWOW WOW WOW. I went here last night and fell in love. My mom had been mentioning how good the food was ever since she started going here with my aunt a few months ago. We ordered the Greek island sampler platter for our appetizer and everything tasted great! Only thing that could have been a little tastier was the feta cheese they have imported. When I visit my family in Astoria and buy feta from queens, it usually tastes a little more flavorful. But I went in there wanting to order a Greek salad but for some reason when I ordered, I told the waitress I wanted tuna salad on a roll. SO HAPPY I ordered that because it was the best tuna salad I ever had. It's so good I may actually start picking up sandwiches from there to bring to the beach with me because it tasted better than a deli lol. The wait staff was also super friendly. Very impressed. I will be returning read less

Great food Family loves this place. Great food and great service. Menu is varied and agrees with all tastes. They serve breakfast,... read moreFamily loves this place. Great food and great service. Menu is varied and agrees with all tastes. They serve breakfast, lunch and dinner and their business is brisk, which tells you a lot about the quality of the food and service. read less

What a great experience. We all are familiar with the The theme song from "Cheers " were everybody knows your... read moreWhat a great experience. We all are familiar with the The theme song from "Cheers " were everybody knows your name" The same can be said about the Greek Island Diner.
Family owned and operated. Every visit is like meeting friends.
Great food warm and friendly staff make this place a win every time.
Just cause everyone is great does not mean there are no stand outs.
The young lady at the counter I call "Greek Island Heather" Knows my order with out being told.
The wonderful selection of fresh homemade soups is great.My favorite is the creme of turkey soup.
The other must is the greek classic pistachio. The creamy béchamel sauce is always perfect.

I can not recommend any place more highly this is a local gem, you owe to your self to try it read less

New favorite place. Best gluten free menu and if it's not on the menu they will make you whatever you... read moreNew favorite place. Best gluten free menu and if it's not on the menu they will make you whatever you want totally gluten free. The gf mozzarella sticks and the gf French fries were delicious.
Will definitely come back again. On occasion they have freshly baked desserts that are gluten free. Happen to have the gf walnut torte. Yummy. read less

Well cooked, well managed Huge portions of well cooked Greek and eclectic diner fare. Friendly, efficient waitresses and managers. The gyros have enough lamb... read moreHuge portions of well cooked Greek and eclectic diner fare. Friendly, efficient waitresses and managers. The gyros have enough lamb for 3 people. You must order extra pita to make more wraps. Excellent breakfasts. The bacon is crisp, the rolls fresh, the eggs perfectly prepared. Altogether a big asset for Wading River. read less

Wonderful, friendly place (Angela) with fantastic food. A little hard to spot (in a strip of stores, not a stand... read moreWonderful, friendly place (Angela) with fantastic food. A little hard to spot (in a strip of stores, not a stand alone building) but well worth the effort!! read less

I have been coming here for years, at least once a week, sometimes twice...It started with just breakfast on Sunday... read moreI have been coming here for years, at least once a week, sometimes twice...It started with just breakfast on Sunday mornings and then I got a taste of the other amazing foods that they have...OMG...best gyros on long island and trust me, I've been around to alot of diners! (In construction for 31 years) Lamb/beef gyro meat is freshly grilled and amazing, pita is lightly grilled as well to put the magic touch on this great lunch favorite. If its your first time, get the gyros if nothing else with the yogurt sauce, even for breakfast lol, you wont be disappointed and if you are, Write me and I will get you proper psychiatric care at a local facility. One of my favorite soups is the seafood bisque and the matzo ball soup, my favorite breakfast is the greek omelette but you must add the greek olives in it, delish ! My favorite entree is tough, (1) spartan chicken with penne pasta (see photo), (2) chicken sorrentino (amazing), rack of lamb when they offer the special. Greek salad is very good as well, I recommend it with anchovies if you like them, gyro meat on the side and some grilled pita to make a little wrap with it (its an Italian thing lol) The dessert looks fabulous but I've never had room to try it! Now you see why I have to work out 4 days a week! read less

Time and again this diner is just great, especially the service. The servers are always just wonderful and as... read moreTime and again this diner is just great, especially the service. The servers are always just wonderful and as pleasant as can be. The food is solid diner food and nothing is too greasy or buttery, and all served with the biggest smile. I like gyro sandwiches. read less

Very Good Food and Priced Right This is the first time that we've been here since they expanded, and it's so much roomier than before. We... read moreThis is the first time that we've been here since they expanded, and it's so much roomier than before. We didn't have to wait for a table, and our food didn't take long to come out.I ordered stuffed flounder and it came with a salad, two very large pieces of fish, potatoes and a vegetable. All that for $19.99, which I thought was a good deal. My husband ordered a BLT sandwich, which was very thick, and he said tasted good. The service was friendly and attentive which added to the enjoyment of our meal. read less

AWESOME! My husband and I just had a baby and rarely leave the house. The Greek island diner delivered two... read moreAWESOME! My husband and I just had a baby and rarely leave the house. The Greek island diner delivered two delicious gyros to my house along with a yummy spanakopita and crispy fries! I moved to Ridge 3 years and had no idea there were any other delivery options other than pizza or Chinese. I highly recommend this place! My husband and I would give them 10 stars if we could! read less

My absolute favorite diner! The staff is so great, they make the best omelettes, the food is always tasty and... read moreMy absolute favorite diner! The staff is so great, they make the best omelettes, the food is always tasty and you get so much food in one order , it's a nice quiet diner, very clean and they are pretty quick with bringing the food out, i would 100% recommend anyone to go here. read less

the food is really good! my friends and i went last night and we had joscelyn as our server and... read morethe food is really good! my friends and i went last night and we had joscelyn as our server and she was very attentive and friendly ! read less

Loved the food..the variety was great. Will be going back for the different flavors.

Great food made fresh ! Excellent food and caring staff and owners that make you fell like you are at a friends or relatives for... read moreExcellent food and caring staff and owners that make you fell like you are at a friends or relatives for dinner! all fresh and homemade tasting, from breakfast to dinner they serve it all fresh hot and a smile all at a reasonable price! read less

Most diners on Long Island are decent, but somewhat skeevy in my opinion. This place calls itself a "diner" they... read moreMost diners on Long Island are decent, but somewhat skeevy in my opinion. This place calls itself a "diner" they have most diner type food, but at regular restaurant quality. Every time I'm here my order comes out in decent time, it's always cooked well, and the food is always good. So if you want really good food at diner prices stop in and enjoy. read less

What a great experience at the Greek Island Diner. My wife and I went here for breakfast and has... read moreWhat a great experience at the Greek Island Diner. My wife and I went here for breakfast and has some amazing gyro hash, pumpkin waffles, and each got our own omelette. Everything came out very quickly and the staff was attentive and nice. We will definitely be going back anytime we go out east on the island for pumpkin picking, apple picking, wineries, or just to the outlets. I have even stopped there after golfing at tallgrass or any other courses on sound avenue. read less

We LOVE this place!
The owners of the GID know the importance of customer service. This is the type of... read moreWe LOVE this place!
The owners of the GID know the importance of customer service. This is the type of place where you almost never hear "no" to a special request and you're always greeted with warmth and hospitality.
Their very efficient and their delivery is the fastest in the area, hands down.
Breakfast is great as well as lunch, dinner and desserts. What I find hilarious is that with a town that hosts 5 pizzerias the GID has the best mozzarella sticks in town lol.
Be prepared when you get the Greek salad because in addition to being delicious they are HUGE.
We also love the falafel and hummus pita, try it.
The paninis are great, as well as the Greek specialties and burgers.
Can't say enough great things! read less