Always a pleasure eating here. The staff is extremely friendly and the food is always delicious. Highly recommended for breakfast,... read moreAlways a pleasure eating here. The staff is extremely friendly and the food is always delicious. Highly recommended for breakfast, lunch or dinner! read less

The best food in town

I've been driving past this place for years and finally stopped here for lunch.
Upon entering the place is way... read moreI've been driving past this place for years and finally stopped here for lunch.
Upon entering the place is way bigger than it looks from the outside. You get that old school diner vibe but with a modern homey type charm.
The place was packed but we were seated immediately and greeted by very friendly staff.
We decided to just order a couple of apps because we couldn't decide on one thing.
Everything we ordered was excellent. I love Spanakopita and this was the best I've had in quite a while. Oh and that yogurt sauce. SO GOOD. I could have eaten it out of the bowl like it was soup.
Our waitress was a sweetheart as was the women at the counter when we left to pay.
So glad I finally stopped in ! Can't wait to come back again. read less

I have eaten here often food is terrific always fresh tonite server was Erin she was very attentive and went... read moreI have eaten here often food is terrific always fresh tonite server was Erin she was very attentive and went out of her way to make sure we were taken care of the restaurant is clean and decorated festively for Christmas we will definitely be back soon read less

Had breakfast there this morning. Potato pancakes were awesome! (Not on the menu-but they will make them if you ask).... read moreHad breakfast there this morning. Potato pancakes were awesome! (Not on the menu-but they will make them if you ask). My kids had waffles with ice cream, which was a super cool treat. The service was great too! Wonderful place for breakfast! read less

The staff is so friendly and attentive. This place has amazing authentic Greek food. The portions are large and always... read moreThe staff is so friendly and attentive. This place has amazing authentic Greek food. The portions are large and always fresh. There is a wide variety of choices and the place is great for families. The restaurant is always so clean. This is great for dining in but the take out is just as good. The take out is always fresh and ready at the time they suggest. read less

Lunch The service is always good. The Son is the best cook going .always cooks the perfect . Mikie is so... read moreThe service is always good. The Son is the best cook going .always cooks the perfect . Mikie is so good getting my tea soon as I walk n the door his on it .Kim does a great job at the front, she runs a tight ship n that's a good thing . read less

Perfect and cconvenient We had lunch and 2 breakfasts here while on our "girls getaway". The menu is huge and everything that everyone... read moreWe had lunch and 2 breakfasts here while on our "girls getaway". The menu is huge and everything that everyone got was excellent (salads, paninis, omelets, etc). read less

Fresh and delicious! I'm always happy with the freshness, quality ingredients and friendly people there. Can't say a bad thing.

This diner is 96% of my desire to move to Wading River. Luckily, one of my best friends lives right... read moreThis diner is 96% of my desire to move to Wading River. Luckily, one of my best friends lives right around the corner and I've enjoyed multiple amazing breakfasts at the Greek Island Diner. I always get an omelette, and it's always huge and delicious, no matter what kind I get. I can never eat that much in the morning, but I always leave a clean plate here. The waitstaff is always super accommodating with substitutions and splitting checks. Also, this place is so affordable and you get so much food! It's super clean and honestly, the perfect diner. SO glad they were able to expand to the second storefront. read less

The best! We catered from them , short notice and all was accommodated and delicious!
We have catered from... read moreThe best! We catered from them , short notice and all was accommodated and delicious!
We have catered from them before as well!
Always fresh and delicious food! read less

Great food, quick friendly service at a fair price! The great part is that they can make most menu items... read moreGreat food, quick friendly service at a fair price! The great part is that they can make most menu items gluten free! My wife has celiacs disease and mentioned it to the waiter and he told us they actually have many gluten free options which is great because she has celiacs disease and cannot eat wheat. Wonderful food and friendly. Will be back! read less

Great food made fresh ! Excellent food and caring staff and owners that make you fell like you are at a friends or relatives for... read moreExcellent food and caring staff and owners that make you fell like you are at a friends or relatives for dinner! all fresh and homemade tasting, from breakfast to dinner they serve it all fresh hot and a smile all at a reasonable price! read less

Excellent Food and Service Marian and Andy run a wonderful Greek diner, with delicious food and great service. The servers and always polite and... read moreMarian and Andy run a wonderful Greek diner, with delicious food and great service. The servers and always polite and friendly. The restaurant and especially the bathrooms are always clean. I come here often either alone or with friends and have never had a disappointing meal. I also recently attended a surprise birthday party catered by Greek Island Diner and the food was amazing! There was a make-your-own Greek salad bar with all the fixings, and a variety of hot and cold foods. Truly delicious and plentiful! Consider them for your next catered party! read less

1 of the best diners in all of long island. Family owned and operated, and amazing staff that has been... read more1 of the best diners in all of long island. Family owned and operated, and amazing staff that has been there for a very long time. The food is always fresh and prepared to order. Also great for take out. Newly expanded to acomadate it's growing followers. If you are looking for diner food this is the place to go. read less

Love the small diner feel, place is always busy. Food is decent size portion and yummy.

Great food Family loves this place. Great food and great service. Menu is varied and agrees with all tastes. They serve breakfast,... read moreFamily loves this place. Great food and great service. Menu is varied and agrees with all tastes. They serve breakfast, lunch and dinner and their business is brisk, which tells you a lot about the quality of the food and service. read less

Very Good Food and Priced Right This is the first time that we've been here since they expanded, and it's so much roomier than before. We... read moreThis is the first time that we've been here since they expanded, and it's so much roomier than before. We didn't have to wait for a table, and our food didn't take long to come out.I ordered stuffed flounder and it came with a salad, two very large pieces of fish, potatoes and a vegetable. All that for $19.99, which I thought was a good deal. My husband ordered a BLT sandwich, which was very thick, and he said tasted good. The service was friendly and attentive which added to the enjoyment of our meal. read less

Most diners on Long Island are decent, but somewhat skeevy in my opinion. This place calls itself a "diner" they... read moreMost diners on Long Island are decent, but somewhat skeevy in my opinion. This place calls itself a "diner" they have most diner type food, but at regular restaurant quality. Every time I'm here my order comes out in decent time, it's always cooked well, and the food is always good. So if you want really good food at diner prices stop in and enjoy. read less

Our favorite place to have breakfast. Staff is always super nice and accommodating. Food is very good and prices are reasonable.

Went for their Tuesday greek night.. it was delicious! Small salad was big enough for dinner and left overs for... read moreWent for their Tuesday greek night.. it was delicious! Small salad was big enough for dinner and left overs for lunch the next day! I added the gyro meat and it was so good! Will def be back soon! read less

Great place to eat !!!!!!! The owners are friendly and so is the staff. The owners were concerned when... read moreGreat place to eat !!!!!!! The owners are friendly and so is the staff. The owners were concerned when I was having trouble, they were right there to help???? read less

BREAKFAST GREAT GREEK OMELTTE. only place to go for one. covid compliance. breakfast was hot not just warm. Waitress friendly.

We have eaten here 2 times on our Long Island stay. There has never been a wait but it's always... read moreWe have eaten here 2 times on our Long Island stay. There has never been a wait but it's always busy. The staff is super friendly, prompt, and coffee always filled.
The food is great, large filling portions. I had the Greek omelet one morning....filled with tangy feta, tomatoes, and spinach and 3 fluffy eggs. Rye toast and home fries kept me full till past noon.
This morning, I had a Belgian waffle with 2 perfectly cooked over medium eggs. The waffle was rich and crispy. Coffee is great as well.
Lots of regular breakfast options, as well as lunch too. And yes, they have Greek food. read less